Recent warnings from major financial institutions about potential US stagflation have dominated market discourse, with JPMorgan stating it sees the US facing a "stagflationary" period and the Federal Reserve flagging stagflation as a risk in its May meeting minutes. However, a data-driven analysis reveals a more nuanced picture that challenges the prevailing narrative. While acknowledging legitimate concerns about growth deceleration and policy uncertainty under the Trump administration's volatile trade approach, our econometric modelling suggests the probability of sustained stagflation remains materially lower than market sentiment implies.
By: Bastian Teichgreeber, Chief Investment Officer at Prescient Investment Management.
The stagflation warning has emerged repeatedly over recent years, yet each iteration has failed to materialize into sustained economic reality. What distinguishes the current environment is the confluence of Trump administration policies that have created significant confidence shocks through erratic trade policy implementation, delayed deregulation initiatives, and an increasingly uncertain fiscal trajectory. However, as statistician George Box famously observed, "All models are wrong, but some are useful" – and distinguishing between useful signal and market noise requires systematic analytical frameworks rather than headline-driven investment approaches. The challenge for investors lies not in the availability of information, but in processing vast data streams to identify genuine economic inflection points. Traditional market participants often fall prey to recency bias and narrative-driven analysis, focusing disproportionately on sensational headlines while missing subtle but significant shifts in underlying economic fundamentals. This is precisely where systematic investment approaches demonstrate their superiority – by consistently applying rigorous analytical frameworks that cut through emotional market reactions to identify genuine value opportunities.
Our proprietary nowcasting model, the Prescient Economic Indicator, currently suggests a growth rate approaching zero – hardly euphoric, but equally distant from recessionary territory. This metric synthesizes hard economic data with soft indicators including consumer surveys, business confidence metrics, investor sentiment, and financial conditions, providing a more comprehensive real-time economic assessment than traditional lagged GDP measurements. While growth has indeed decelerated markedly, the underlying hard data remains sufficiently robust to avoid deeper recessionary dynamics. The key insight for investors is recognizing that growth deceleration does not automatically translate to stagflation. Our analysis indicates that while growth momentum has weakened, the structural foundation for sustained economic expansion remains intact.
The inflation component of the stagflation equation presents an even more compelling case against the prevailing narrative. Three structural deflationary forces continue to exert downward pressure on price levels: Disruption, Debt, and Demographics. Technological disruption, which we view as particularly significant, simultaneously enhances productivity growth while reducing input costs across numerous sectors. This dynamic creates a favourable environment for sustained growth with contained inflation – the opposite of stagflation. The composition of current US inflation further supports this thesis, with the shelter component representing the primary driver of price pressures. Housing-related inflation correlates strongly with labour market tightness and housing market dynamics, both showing increasing signs of moderation. Regarding Trump's trade policies, empirical analysis suggests tariffs generate one-time price level adjustments rather than sustained inflationary momentum. While tariffs undoubtedly reduce growth efficiency, they typically create temporary price shocks that dissipate once economic agents adjust to new trade equilibria. Counter-intuitively, tariffs may support the disinflationary thesis by reducing growth momentum more than they elevate sustained price pressures. Forward-looking inflation metrics, when observed multidimensionally rather than focusing solely on one-year horizons, corroborate this analysis. Our approach to inflation forecasting incorporates alternative data sources and machine learning techniques that traditional economic models overlook, providing superior predictive accuracy.
While we assign low probability to sustained stagflation, the primary market risk now lies in Federal Reserve policy miscalibration. The greatest threat to US economic stability would be delayed monetary policy response to weakening growth conditions, potentially triggering the very recessionary dynamics that policymakers seek to avoid. This scenario could precipitate a global growth shock with significant cross-asset implications. Our risk management framework assigns higher probability to Fed policy errors than to endogenous stagflation development. This distinction is crucial for portfolio positioning, as the optimal hedge strategies differ significantly between these scenarios.
The current environment exemplifies why systematic investment approaches outperform discretionary alternatives during periods of elevated uncertainty. While traditional investors chase headlines and narrative-driven themes, systematic approaches maintain disciplined focus on empirically validated relationships between economic fundamentals and asset prices. The stagflation narrative, while compelling from a storytelling perspective, lacks empirical support when subjected to rigorous analysis. Trump's trade policies, despite creating short-term volatility, are unlikely to generate the sustained inflation acceleration necessary for true stagflation. Instead, structural disinflationary forces combined with policy-induced growth moderation suggest a more benign economic trajectory. For investors, the current environment presents opportunities to capitalize on market mispricing driven by narrative-focused investment approaches. By maintaining disciplined adherence to data-driven analysis while others chase headlines, systematic strategies can deliver superior risk-adjusted returns precisely when traditional approaches falter. The path forward requires continued vigilance regarding Fed policy responses while maintaining confidence in systematic analytical frameworks that consistently outperform emotion-driven market reactions. In an era of information abundance, the competitive advantage belongs to those who can systematically distinguish signal from noise – precisely the domain where systematic investment approaches excel.
Disclaimer:
Prescient Investment Management (Pty) Ltd is an authorised Financial Services Provider (FSP 612). Please note that there are risks involved in buying or selling a financial product, and past performance of a financial product is not necessarily a guide to future performance. The value of financial products can increase as well as decrease over time, depending on the value of the underlying securities and market conditions. There is no guarantee in respect of capital or returns in a portfolio. No action should be taken on the basis of this information without first seeking independent professional advice.
The information contained herein is provided for general information purposes only. The information and does not constitute or form part of any offer to issue or sell or any solicitation of any offer to subscribe for or purchase any particular investments. Opinions and views expressed in this document may be changed without notice at any time after publication and are, unless otherwise stated, those of the author and all rights are reserved. The information contained herein may contain proprietary information. The content of any document released or posted by Prescient is for information purposes only and is protected by copy right laws. We therefore disclaim any liability for any loss, liability, damage (whether direct or consequential) or expense of any nature whatsoever which may be suffered as a result of or which may be attributable directly or indirectly to the use of or reliance upon the information. For more information, visit www.prescient.co.za.
